Real creators or AI UGC: which should I use?

Updated 4 min read

Short answer

Use AI UGC when you need many quick variations of a line and a generated presenter is fine for the job. Use real creators when you want a real person on camera, talking about your product in their own voice. ContentCraze is real creators only, at $35 for each video you approve up to 60 seconds, with first videos in as quick as 12 hours after your campaign goes live.

On this page

What AI UGC tools do well

AI UGC tools turn a script into a talking presenter video without a camera or a creator. For some jobs that is a real help.

  • Speed. A new version can be made in the tool, at any hour, with no shoot.
  • Low cost per variation. Once you have a tool, each extra version usually costs less than a new shoot.
  • Nothing to ship. The presenter never needs the product in hand.
  • Easy edits. Change a word in the script and make the video again.

Where buyers hesitate with AI UGC

These are the questions to weigh before you put an AI presenter in an ad.

  • Faces that look generated. Small things in the skin, mouth or hands can give it away, and a viewer who notices may doubt the rest of the ad.
  • Disclosure. If the ad carries an AI label, that changes how it reads.
  • No real person. A generated presenter is not someone a viewer could ever meet.
  • Shared presenters. Stock presenters can turn up in other brands' ads too.

What real creator UGC does well

A real creator films on their own phone, in their own space, talking about your product or app in their own voice. The video looks and sounds like a real person talking to you, because it is one.

Real creators react, add their own tone, and say the script in their own way. An order of up to five videos of one script, each from a different creator, gives you different faces, voices and settings to test.

Real creator UGC used to mean briefs, messages, shipping and waiting. ContentCraze takes that work off you: you approve a short script (we draft it from a few lines, or you write your own), creators choose your campaign, and every take is checked before you see it. You can watch finished videos at contentcraze.io/examples.

On ContentCraze nothing has to ship: you upload photos, clips, screenshots or a screen recording, and each video is edited around your shots.

When each one fits

You can use both: AI to sketch ideas, then real creators for the ads you plan to run. Here is how the two compare.

QuestionAI UGCReal creators
Who is on cameraA generated presenterA real person
How the product appearsIn images or clips you supplyA real person talks about it on camera; on ContentCraze each video is edited around your photos, clips or screenshots
Good forMany quick versions of one lineAds where you want a real face
SpeedFast, made in the toolOn ContentCraze, first videos in as quick as 12 hours after your campaign goes live
AI UGC and real creator UGC, side by side

Real creators on ContentCraze for $35 a video

Here is how it works.

  • $35 for each video you approve up to 60 seconds, $69 over 60 seconds, $3 more if the creator also posts it from their own TikTok or Instagram.
  • $0 up front. A card is saved at sign-up, and each video is charged about a minute after you approve it. No subscription to buy by the video.
  • Orders are up to five videos of one script. Two creators film first, and the other three start after you approve your first video. You see the most an order can cost: $175 for five videos up to 60 seconds, $190 if creators also post them.
  • Takes marked Not approved cost nothing, and an approved video is final. A take left undecided for 48 hours counts as approved, with two reminders first.
  • Every video you approve and pay for is yours, paid ads included.
  • Want no creators to manage at all? See UGC without managing creators.
  • Full terms are at contentcraze.io/pricing, and contentcraze.io/ugc-video-cost compares how other services charge.

Questions, answered.

Is AI UGC the same as real UGC?

No. AI UGC uses a generated presenter reading your script. Real UGC is a real person filming on their own phone, talking about your product.

Does ContentCraze use AI creators?

No. Every ContentCraze video is filmed by a real creator on their own phone, never AI.

Can I get real creator videos without shipping my product?

Yes. Upload photos, short clips, screenshots or a screen recording. Creators talk about it on camera, and each video is edited around your shots, so nothing has to ship.

How fast are real creator videos on ContentCraze?

First videos in as quick as 12 hours after your campaign goes live. The rest land as creators finish.

What does a real creator video cost on ContentCraze?

$35 for each video you approve up to 60 seconds, or $69 over 60 seconds. Nothing is charged up front, and takes marked Not approved cost nothing. A take left undecided for 48 hours counts as approved, and we remind you twice first.

Should I use AI UGC and real creators together?

You can. AI can help you sketch a lot of lines quickly, and real creators film the ones you want a real face behind.

Sources (3)

  1. ContentCraze

    contentcraze.io